Problem 1
- Test level
- Multiple choice
- No calculator
- 4 pts
Functions and satisfy , , , , , and is undefined. Which of the following limits exist?
Answer
I and II only. Sum: from the left and from the right. Product: and . Quotient: and , which differ.
Full solution
Neither nor has a two-sided limit at , so the limit laws (which need each limit to exist) do not apply. Fall back on one-sided limits: each one-sided limit does exist, and one-sided limits obey the sum, product and quotient laws.
The rule that saves you: combine left with left and right with right. Never mix a left-hand value of with a right-hand value of .
I. From the left: . From the right: . They agree, so exists. Graphically, jumps down by exactly where jumps up by , so the jumps cancel.
II. From the left: . From the right: . They agree, so exists.
III. From the left: . From the right: . Neither denominator limit is , so each one-sided limit is fine, but they differ. The quotient's limit does not exist.
So exactly I and II exist: choice (B). The values and undefined are distractions; they play no role in any of these limits.
Why the other choices tempt people. (E) comes from believing that if neither part has a limit, no combination can. (A) comes from trusting the sum but assuming a product of two jumps must still jump. (D) comes from pairing the wrong sides (left of with right of ): that pairing gives for III and different answers for I and II. (C) comes from extending the pattern without checking III.
Where students lose points
Pairing the wrong sides, or concluding "does not exist" for every combination because and each jump. Write a two-column table, left and right, compute each combination in its own column, and compare.

