Problem 1
- Test level
- Multiple choice
- No calculator
- 4 pts
Two point charges sit on the -axis: charge at and charge at . The positive charge is known to be . The graph shows the -component of the net field along the axis against ; the dashed lines mark and . The only point where the curve crosses zero is . (Between and the curve lies far above the top of the window.) Which statement about charge is correct?
Answer
(B). At the zero crossing the two fields have equal size: , so . A zero outside the pair needs opposite signs, so .
Full solution
A point where is a point where the two fields cancel, so they must be equal in size: .
Read the distances from the graph: the zero is at , so and .
Then . The charges scale with the square of the distances, not the distances themselves.
Sign: the zero lies outside the pair, on the far side of . Between the charges the two fields of unlike-sign charges point the same way and can never cancel, and outside the pair they point opposite ways. So and have opposite signs, and .
Consistency with the picture: the larger charge is the farther one from the zero point, as it must be, since the field of a larger charge needs more distance to weaken to the size of the smaller charge's field. Far to the right the net charge is , matching the negative values there.
Where students lose points
Taking the ratio of distances instead of the ratio of their squares (choice A), or putting the larger charge at the nearer point (choice D). The null point always sits closer to the smaller charge. Choice (C) ignores that a zero outside the pair needs opposite signs, and choice (E) mixes both errors.

