Problem 1
- Test level
- Multiple choice
- No calculator
- 4 pts
Points , , and lie on one line. , , and is the midpoint of . Nothing is said about the order of the points. What are all the possible values of ?
Answer
or , because can lie on either side of and each case gives a different midpoint.
Full solution
Because no order is given, put the points on a number line instead of trusting a picture. Put at and at (the other way round is a mirror image and gives the same distances).
means is away from , so or . Both are legal, and nothing in the problem rules either one out.
Case 1: (between and ). Then is the midpoint of and : , so .
Case 2: (on the other side of ). Then , so .
Both values are possible, so the answer is or . Choice (A) assumes the order ; choice (C) assumes the order ; choice (D) reports instead of (forgetting to halve); choice (E) is half of , ignoring .
Where students lose points
Assuming the points are in the order they are named. When a problem says only that points are collinear, check every position a point can take. Here allows two positions for .

