The Supreme Court's 2023 SFFA ruling ended race-conscious admissions, but it also created a new strategic reality: students can, and should, write about their racial or cultural experiences in essays. The Court explicitly said so. Chief Justice Roberts: "Nothing in this opinion should be construed as prohibiting universities from considering an applicant's discussion of how race affected his or her life."
Here's the practical landscape. Before: colleges could consider race as one factor among many in a "holistic" admissions process. After: colleges cannot use race as a factor in admissions decisions. But students may write about how their race or ethnicity has shaped their lives and perspectives. That last part is where essay strategy comes in.
How colleges are adapting their essay prompts
Post-SFFA, schools are adding more explicit prompts inviting students to share identity-related experiences. These are no longer secondary supplements. They're main essay topics.
Examples from the 2024-2025 cycle: Yale asks you to "reflect on a time when you grew from understanding different perspectives," which opens the door to discussing cultural identity. The Common App's "background, identity, interest, or talent" prompt explicitly invites identity discussion. These prompts are strategic on the schools' part. They want context they can no longer get from a checkbox.
Write about impact, not identity alone
Weak: "I am proud to be Latino."
Strong: "Growing up in a bilingual household, I've become the family translator, handling insurance forms, parent-teacher conferences, and medical appointments. This role taught me advocacy, patience, and the power of language to bridge divides."
The strong version works because it demonstrates skills, values, and growth, not just identity.
Connect identity to intellectual curiosity
Show how your background shaped your academic interests. "My grandmother's stories of the Partition of India sparked my fascination with post-colonial literature. I spent my junior year researching Salman Rushdie's work, exploring how migration and identity shape narrative voice." This connects personal experience to genuine academic engagement.
Discuss challenges, but focus on agency
It's fine to discuss adversity, but center your response, not victimhood.
Instead of: "Racism made high school hard."
Try: "When I was the only Black student in AP Calc, I founded a mentorship program to recruit underrepresented students into STEM. It's now 15 members strong."
Be specific and personal
Avoid generalities. Use vivid, concrete details that only you could write. Don't say "my culture values family." Show it through a specific family tradition, conversation, or moment.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Resume listing. "I'm Asian, I play violin, I'm in math club." Surface-level, no depth.
- Trauma dumping. Focusing solely on hardship without growth or agency.
- Performative diversity. Writing what you think colleges want to hear instead of your truth.
- Ignoring the prompt. Mentioning identity without tying it to the question asked.
Should you write about race or ethnicity?
Write about it if: it's central to your story and growth, you have specific and compelling examples, it connects to your academic or extracurricular interests, and you can write authentically about it.
Don't write about it if: it feels forced or performative, you have a stronger story elsewhere, you're just mentioning it for "diversity points," or it doesn't add new information to your application.
The bottom line: essays matter more than ever
With race no longer a checkable box, essays are the primary avenue for colleges to understand the full context of your life. If your racial, ethnic, or cultural background has meaningfully shaped who you are, write about it. But do so with nuance, specificity, and a focus on what you've learned and how you'll contribute.
The SFFA ruling didn't end the importance of diversity in admissions. It shifted how students communicate it.
Helpful resources
- Common Application Essay Prompts - Current Common App essay prompts
- College Board - College planning and admissions resources
- NACAC - National Association for College Admission Counseling