The single most important thing to know about alumni interviews: they are not trying to trick you. Alumni interviewers are volunteers who genuinely want to help the admissions committee get to know you better. The interview is your chance to be a person, not just a file.
What the interview actually is
Alumni interviews are informational and evaluative, but not in the way most students fear. Interviewers write brief reports that add color to your application. They are not making admission decisions themselves.
Most interviewers have not seen your application. They do not know your GPA, test scores, or essays. They only know your name and school. That actually levels the playing field.
Who are these people?
Alumni interviewers are graduates who volunteer their time because they love their school and want to help. They might be a lawyer, a software engineer, a teacher, or a stay-at-home parent. They are not professional interviewers. They are regular people.
They want a genuine conversation about your interests. They want to understand what makes you tick. They want enthusiasm about their alma mater and thoughtful questions from you. They do not want rehearsed, robotic answers, someone who is clearly performing, arrogance, or zero questions about the school.
Before the interview
Research the school (but do not overdo it).
Know the basics: academic strengths, campus culture, a few specific programs that interest you. Genuine interest beats recited facts.
Know your own story.
Be ready to talk about your activities, interests, and why you are excited about this school. Not a script. Clarity about who you are and what matters to you.
Prepare questions for them.
Alumni love talking about their experience. Ask about their favorite memories, what surprised them, how the school shaped their career. Make the questions specific enough to show real curiosity.
Handle logistics professionally.
Respond to scheduling emails promptly. Show up on time or early. Dress business casual. These basics matter more than you would think.
Questions you will probably get
Most alumni interviewers ask similar questions. The goal is not to catch you off guard. It is to start a conversation.
"Tell me about yourself."
Do not recite your resume. Share what you are passionate about and why. Give them something to ask follow-up questions about.
"Why this school?"
Be specific. "Great academics" is not enough. Mention particular programs, opportunities, or aspects of campus culture that genuinely appeal to you.
"What do you do outside of class?"
Pick one or two activities you are genuinely excited about and go deep. Show what you have learned, built, or contributed.
"What would you contribute to campus?"
Think about this beforehand. What perspectives, interests, or energy would you bring? Be honest about who you are.
"What questions do you have for me?"
This is your moment. Have two or three thoughtful questions ready. Ask about their experience, advice for incoming students, or what they would do differently.
What makes a great interview
The best alumni interviews do not feel like interviews at all. They feel like conversations between two people who are both genuinely interested in each other. Here are the signs you are doing it right:
- It feels like a conversation. There is natural back-and-forth, and time passes quickly.
- You are being yourself. Your genuine personality and interests are coming through, not a performance.
- You are curious about them. You are asking questions because you genuinely want to know, not because you are supposed to.
- You share specific stories. Instead of vague claims about leadership, you share concrete examples that stick in memory.
Mistakes that hurt you
- Treating it as one-directional. If you never ask questions or show curiosity about the interviewer, you seem disengaged.
- Over-rehearsed answers. Prepared does not mean scripted. If your answers sound memorized, the conversation feels fake.
- Badmouthing your current school. Even if you are unhappy, stay positive. Complaining reflects poorly on you.
- Focusing only on prestige. "I want to go here because it is highly ranked" tells them nothing about you.
- Skipping the thank-you note. A brief, genuine email within 24 hours shows maturity and appreciation. Reference something specific from your conversation.
Virtual interview tips
Many interviews now happen over Zoom or phone. A few adjustments make a big difference. For video calls: test your tech beforehand, choose a quiet space with good lighting, look at the camera rather than your own image, and dress the same as you would in person. For phone calls: find somewhere quiet, sit up straight (posture affects voice), smile while you talk (it comes through), and keep notes nearby without reading from them.
The real secret
Your job is not to impress them. It is to connect with them. Be curious, be genuine, and remember that they are rooting for you. They want to write a glowing report. Give them something to write about.
Helpful resources
- Glassdoor - Interview questions and company reviews
- Bureau of Labor Statistics - Career and salary data
- LinkedIn - Professional networking and job search