Crafting compelling Phillips Andover essays

October 2024EduAvenues Team3 min read

When most applicants have stellar transcripts and impressive extracurriculars, the essays become the most critical differentiator. That is not a platitude. At Andover's acceptance rate, the reader needs a reason to say yes, and the essay is where that reason lives.

Why the essays matter more than you think

When the majority of applicants possess straight A's and 90th-percentile-plus test scores, the essay is where admissions officers search for three things:

  • Voice. Who is this student beyond the numbers?
  • Fit. Will they thrive in Andover's intellectual and social environment?
  • Potential. Do they demonstrate the curiosity, resilience, and character Andover values?

Decoding the prompts

Andover's essay prompts are deliberately open-ended. They are not trick questions. They are invitations to think deeply and write honestly.

When a prompt asks you to "tell us about a time you challenged yourself intellectually," it is not asking for a list of hard classes. It is asking: How do you engage with ideas? Do you seek challenges, or do you avoid them? What happened the last time something was genuinely hard for you?

When a prompt asks about a community you belong to, it is asking: Are you a giver or a taker? Do you understand that Andover is a community, and that membership requires contribution?

What makes an essay stand out

Specificity beats generality

"I love science and have always been curious about the world around me" tells the reader nothing. "Last summer, I spent six weeks isolating enzymes from soil bacteria in Dr. Chen's lab, which led to a small finding about antibiotic resistance" tells the reader everything.

Show, do not tell

Admissions officers do not want to be told that you are "hardworking," "curious," or "resilient." They want evidence. Do not write "I am passionate about social justice." Write "Every Saturday for two years, I tutored immigrant students in English, watching them gain confidence to speak up in class."

Authentic voice

The essay should sound like a 13-to-15-year-old wrote it. Intelligent and thoughtful, yes. But not like a college professor. Overwrought vocabulary and purple prose are red flags. Be yourself.

Reflection, not just description

Strong essays do not just describe what happened. They reflect on what it meant. The "so what?" is often more important than the "what."

Common pitfalls

01

The "Thesaurus Essay"

Using big words to sound smart. It reads as inauthentic, and admissions readers spot it immediately.

02

The "Resume Repeat"

Listing accomplishments without insight. The essay is not another activities list. If your essay could be replaced by a spreadsheet, rewrite it.

03

The "Victim Narrative"

Focusing solely on hardship without demonstrating growth or agency. Adversity is fine to write about, but the essay needs to show what you did with it.

04

The "AI-Generated" Essay

Admissions officers can spot these. They lack authentic voice and specificity. They are grammatically clean and emotionally empty. Write it yourself.

A note for parents

Parents should support, not write. Your role is to ask probing questions that help your child reflect, proofread for grammar (not content), encourage authenticity over perfection, and trust that your child's voice is enough.

If the essay sounds like it was written by an adult, that is worse than a few rough sentences. The reader wants to hear a teenager thinking. Let them.

Helpful resources

  • SSAT Official : Secondary School Admission Test
  • TABS : The Association of Boarding Schools
  • NAIS : National Association of Independent Schools

Start Andover Prep Flex free

Work through the first module of Andover Prep Flex, free with any email and no card.

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

More on Andover admissions

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.