Andover vs. Exeter: a deep comparison

October 2024EduAvenues Team3 min read

Both are extraordinary schools with legendary reputations and college placement records. They share the Phillips name (and a common founder). But beneath the surface, they offer meaningfully different experiences, and the right choice depends on your child.

Here is how they compare across the dimensions that actually matter for families making this decision.

At a glance

Phillips Exeter Academy: Founded 1781 in Exeter, NH. About 1,100 students. Endowment over $1.3 billion. Acceptance rate around 15%.

Phillips Academy Andover: Founded 1778 in Andover, MA. About 1,150 students. Endowment over $1.2 billion. Acceptance rate around 13%.

The Harkness Method: a shared foundation with different approaches

Both schools use the legendary Harkness Method, a discussion-based pedagogy conducted around oval tables that was invented at Exeter in 1930 with a $5.8 million gift from Edward Harkness. But the schools implement it quite differently.

Exeter is a Harkness purist. The oval table is central to virtually every class. Faculty guide discussions but rarely lecture. Students are expected to come prepared to lead conversations, defend positions, and challenge peers respectfully. It is 100% Harkness in most subjects, student-driven, with minimal direct instruction and heavy emphasis on preparation and participation.

Andover takes a hybrid approach. They also use Harkness tables, but with more pedagogical flexibility. Teachers may shift between discussion, lecture, lab work, and presentations depending on the subject and material. Harkness is one tool among many, with more teacher-guided moments and greater format variety.

Which learning style fits your child?

Exeter may suit students who: thrive in pure discussion environments, are comfortable speaking up in class, enjoy intellectual debate and challenge, and learn best through dialogue and questioning.

Andover may suit students who: appreciate variety in teaching styles, benefit from some direct instruction, are still developing classroom confidence, and prefer pedagogical flexibility.

Campus culture and student atmosphere

Exeter students often describe the culture as intensely intellectual and introspective. The campus has a more reserved, studious atmosphere. Students are deeply engaged in their work, and there is a sense of academic competition (though largely self-imposed). The motto "Non Sibi" (not for oneself) emphasizes service and community, but the day-to-day feel is quieter and more focused.

Andover's culture is often described as more balanced and extroverted. While academics are rigorous, students emphasize a strong sense of community and collaboration. The "Blue Key" tradition (student-led campus tours) and various social traditions foster school spirit. The motto "Youth From Every Quarter" highlights diversity and inclusion.

Location and campus feel

Exeter, New Hampshire: 45 minutes to Boston. Small town (population around 15,000). More isolated, insular campus. The campus feels like its own world. Quintessential New England town.

Andover, Massachusetts: 30 minutes to Boston. Larger town (population around 35,000). More suburban feel. Easier access to urban amenities. More connection to the outside world.

The bottom line

Both schools are extraordinary. Both produce exceptional college outcomes. Both offer world-class faculty, resources, and opportunities. The decision should come down to fit and learning style.

Choose Exeter if your child thrives in pure discussion environments, values intellectual intensity above all, prefers a smaller and more insular community, and is comfortable with less hand-holding.

Choose Andover if your child wants pedagogical variety, values school spirit and community, prefers proximity to urban areas, and benefits from varied learning formats.

Visit both campuses if possible. Attend classes, talk to current students, and trust your instincts. The "better" school is the one where your child will flourish academically, socially, and personally.

Helpful resources

  • SSAT Official : Secondary School Admission Test
  • TABS : The Association of Boarding Schools
  • NAIS : National Association of Independent Schools

Start Andover Prep Flex free

Work through the first module of Andover Prep Flex, free with any email and no card.

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

More on Andover admissions

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.