"Just be yourself" is terrible college admissions advice

March 2024Neil, Co-Founder5 min read

At some point during the college application process, almost every student gets the same well-meaning piece of advice: just be yourself.

It sounds nice. It suggests that if you are authentic enough, the rest will sort itself out. It is also one of the least useful things you can tell a 17 year old trying to stand out in an application pile.

"Be yourself" assumes authenticity is a strategy. It is not. Plenty of genuine, interesting students submit applications that are completely forgettable, not because they are not impressive, but because they did not know how to communicate what makes them impressive.

Why the advice falls flat

The advice usually comes from a good place. People are trying to say: do not fake it, do not fabricate experiences, do not write the essay you think admissions officers want. All true. Inauthenticity is easy to spot and almost always backfires.

But it misses the point. Most students do not know how to present themselves effectively. They are teenagers. They have never had to compress their life into a narrative someone else will read in ten minutes. They do not know which details matter, which to leave out, or how to frame the story so it lands.

What happens when students just "be themselves"

  • Generic essays. The topic is real and meaningful, but the essay reads like thousands of other essays on the same topic. Honest, not memorable.
  • Authentic but irrelevant material. They write about something that matters to them personally but gives the admissions office no new reason to believe they would thrive on that campus.

Neither of those works at selective schools. Not because authenticity is bad, but because authenticity without intent tends to blend in.

What admissions officers are actually doing

During peak season a single reader might get through 30 to 50 applications a day. They are looking for reasons to say yes, but they are also looking for ways to quickly sort a huge pile. When they open yours, they are asking four questions:

  • Who is this person? What do they care about and how do they think?
  • What will they bring to campus? What makes them distinctive in a room full of other admits?
  • Will they succeed here? Is there evidence of the academic and personal stamina the place demands?
  • Do they actually want to come? Is this school a real priority or just another checkbox?

"Be yourself" does not answer any of those. A strategic application does.

Authentic vs. strategic, in practice

Two students both spent their summer volunteering at a food bank. Both cared about the work.

Student A writes an essay about how the experience taught them that helping others is important and that they are grateful for what they have. Sincere. Also something a reader has seen a thousand times.

Student B writes about a specific conversation with a regular client that challenged their assumptions about poverty, which led them to research food insecurity in their area, which eventually led them to start a small initiative at their school. Specific, reflective, concrete.

Both students are being honest. Only one is also being intentional. That is the difference. It is not about being fake. It is about being deliberate with the true things you choose to share.

A better framework

  • Start with real reflection. What do you actually care about? What experiences have changed you? Excavate a narrative, do not invent one.
  • Find the through lines. Strong applications feel coherent. The activities, interests, and essays should add up to a clear picture of one person.
  • Be specific. "I learned the value of hard work" could be written by anyone. "I spent three months debugging a single line of code and realized I actually enjoy the frustration" tells the reader something real.
  • Show, do not tell. Instead of saying you are passionate about environmental science, describe what the passion has made you do.
  • Think about the reader. This is not a diary. It is a message to a tired stranger. What would make them remember you at the end of a long day?

The essay trap

The personal essay is where "be yourself" does the most damage. Students read it as permission to write about whatever feels meaningful to them, which leads to topics that are too common (the big game, the service trip, the immigrant grandparent), too personal (unprocessed trauma), or too abstract (a meditation on success).

A good essay topic does three things:

  • It is specific. There is a concrete moment, question, or experience at the center.
  • It reveals something. The reader ends up understanding something real about how you think or what you value.
  • It has not been overdone. The topic, or at least the angle, has not been written by thousands of other applicants in the same way.

Finding that topic takes work. Brainstorming, reflection, a few false starts. It does not happen by accident.

What I would say instead of "be yourself"

Be yourself, but be your most interesting self. Share what is genuinely true about you, and choose the truths that will resonate. Do not pretend to be someone you are not, but present yourself with intention. Authenticity is the foundation. Strategy is how you build on it.

The students who stand out are not usually the most impressive on paper. They are the ones who know how to tell their story in a way that sticks. That is a skill, and like any skill, it can be learned.

Questions worth sitting with

  • If you had to describe what makes you distinctive in two sentences, what would you say? Could someone who knows you agree?
  • Does your application have a clear through line, or does it feel scattered?
  • What is a small experience of yours that actually reveals a lot?
  • Is your essay topic one an admissions officer has likely seen a hundred times? If so, what is a fresher angle on it?
  • Who is giving you feedback, and are they in a position to actually help?

Helpful resources

Until next time,

Neil

Co-Founder, EduAvenues

Read the prompts before you draft

See every supplemental prompt for 30 colleges word for word, with word limits and which ones are required. The first section of CollegePrep Foundations is free to read, with no sign-in.

Want written feedback on your own drafts? Application Studio gives expert help with essays, activities and the final application review.

See Application Studio

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Neil, Co-Founder

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.