When siblings go through admissions differently

January 2025Neil, Co-Founder3 min read

There is a particular kind of tension that shows up in homes with multiple children during admissions season. One sibling got in, the other is waitlisted. One has a clean story and easy essays, the other is still looking for an angle. One is watching an older sibling thrive at a school they could not have gotten into.

If any of that sounds familiar, you are not alone. This is one of the harder emotional situations families hit in this process, and it is worth navigating on purpose.

Why this gets complicated

Siblings are already primed for comparison. They share parents, homes, and often schools. Admissions supercharges that because the outcomes are visible and binary, the timing is staggered, and where you go to college ends up tied to how a kid sees themselves for a while.

Parental bandwidth matters too. The first child often gets enormous energy. The second sometimes gets a tired parent running a playbook from a different kid.

How parents make it worse without meaning to

  • Talking up one child in front of the other. "Your brother got in with those grades" lands as "why aren't you more like him," no matter the intent.
  • Running the same playbook on different kids. What worked for one often does not fit the other. Different interests, different temperaments, different approach.
  • Unequal investment. Hiring a consultant for one and not the other, or visiting ten schools with one and two with the other, sends a message even when the reasons are practical.
  • Using one sibling as a benchmark. "Your sister's essay was done by October" is comparison, even when you do not frame it that way.
  • Assuming matching outcomes. Expecting the same result from a different kid adds pressure that is often neither realistic nor fair.

What actually helps

  • Treat each child as their own applicant. Their own list, their own strategy, their own timeline.
  • Do not compare out loud. They are already comparing themselves. You do not need to add to it.
  • Celebrate each acceptance at full volume. The size of your reaction is the message.
  • Have private conversations. Talk to each child one on one, not with siblings in the room.
  • Name the hard feelings. "I know it is hard to watch your sister celebrate while you are still waiting." Acknowledgment helps more than reassurance.
  • Invest as equitably as you can. When circumstances force a difference, say so out loud.

When one sibling gets in where the other did not

This is the hardest moment, and how you handle it matters a lot.

01

Do not minimize either outcome.

The sibling who got in deserves to celebrate. The sibling who did not deserves to have the disappointment acknowledged. Flattening either one helps no one.

02

Separate the outcome from the child.

Say it plainly: where you go to college does not decide your value. You are both extraordinary regardless of what any committee decided.

03

Let the feelings be complicated.

Jealousy, sadness, and genuine happiness for a sibling can coexist. Let them.

04

Do not let admissions define the relationship.

In ten years no one will remember who got in where. They will remember how the family treated each other during the hard weeks.

The long view

College admissions is a moment. Sibling relationships are a lifetime. The way you handle this stretch will shape those relationships for years. You have more influence than you think.

It takes intentional effort: separate conversations, equitable investment, careful language. Your kids are watching how you handle this. That is the lesson they will remember.

Until next time,

Neil

Co-Founder, EduAvenues

Helpful resources

Check the numbers for every college on the list

Free acceptance rates, early decision and test score ranges by year, from each college’s Common Data Set.

Want help applying this to your own plan? Foundations is our self-paced course for each step. Insider adds a dedicated advisor you can text or email, plus workshops, office hours and resume and application reviews.

Compare Foundations and Insider

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Neil, Co-Founder

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.