Few topics in admissions generate more anxiety than standardized testing. Some families obsess over it, others dismiss it entirely, and a lot of parents are just confused about what to do.
When to start prep is a fair question, but it is not the only one that matters. The bigger questions are: how much prep is enough, when should you switch tests, and when should you accept that the score you have is the score you have.
The landscape in one paragraph
Many schools kept test-optional policies after the pandemic. "Test-optional" is not the same as "test-irrelevant." At most selective schools, strong scores still help. For students with less rigorous transcripts or from less well-known high schools, scores can provide useful evidence of academic ability. The real question is how much scores matter for your child, at the schools on their list, given the rest of their application.
When to start
- Most students. Spring of junior year is plenty early. That leaves time to take the test once or twice and switch to the other test if needed.
- Students targeting very high scores. January or February of junior year gives more room for gradual improvement.
- Students with real content gaps. If the issue is foundational math or reading skill, call it skill-building, not test prep. Start earlier, but do not frame it as prep.
- Avoid freshman-year prep. The material is not fresh, burnout is real, and the priorities should be elsewhere.
How much prep is enough
This varies a lot by student. Some improve significantly in a few weeks of focused practice. Others plateau fast and do not gain much from more hours. The shape of a good plan is always the same.
Start with a diagnostic.
A full timed practice test sets a baseline and shows where the points are actually leaking out.
Set a realistic target.
Look at the middle fifty of the schools on the list. Aim for helpful, not perfect.
Prep where the room is.
If the student is already at 780 math and 650 reading, more math is not the answer.
Monitor every few weeks.
Another practice test. If the number is moving, keep going. If it is not, change something.
Know when to stop.
After several practice tests at the same score despite real effort, that may be the score. More prep is diminishing returns.
SAT vs. ACT
Many students do meaningfully better on one test than the other. Trying both once is almost always worth the afternoon.
- SAT. More reasoning, less time pressure, questions that can be trickier. Rewards students who like to work through problems.
- ACT. More straightforward but faster-paced. Rewards students who manage time well and make quick decisions.
Take a practice version of each and compare. If there is a clear gap, commit to the stronger one. If they are close, pick one and stop thinking about it.
When to go test-optional
- The score sits below the school's middle fifty. Submitting a score that is well below range does not help.
- The score does not reflect the student's academic ability. If the rest of the application is strong and the number would pull against it, leave it off.
- Testing is causing real harm. If prep has become the whole identity of senior year and the score is not moving, stepping back is fine.
- Only after a genuine effort. Going test-optional because the student did not feel like prepping is a different situation than going test-optional because the score is not there.
Keep, pivot, or walk away
- Keep prepping if. Scores are still improving, your child has bandwidth, the score is not yet in a helpful range.
- Pivot to the other test if. Scores have plateaued on one test and you have not tried the other.
- Walk away if. The score has plateaued despite real effort, the current number is good enough for the list, or the stress is outweighing the benefit.
Walking away is not giving up. It is choosing where to spend the last months of high school.
A word about perspective
Test scores are one data point. Students with perfect scores get rejected from everywhere. Students with modest scores get into places families assumed were out of reach. The test matters, it is not everything, and keeping that clear in your head is half the work.
The short version
Diagnose, set a real target, prep where the points are, check the number every few weeks, and decide whether to keep going, switch tests, or stop. Make the decision based on where you are, not where you wish you were.
Until next time,
Neil
Co-Founder, EduAvenues
Helpful resources
- College Board SAT - Official SAT information
- ACT - Official ACT information
- FairTest - Current test-optional school list