Freshman year: what actually matters

February 2024EduAvenues Team4 min read

Most ninth graders should not be preparing for college yet. They should be adjusting to high school, figuring out what they actually like, and building habits that will carry them through the next four years. That is the whole job.

We see two failure modes. One is the family that runs freshman year like an Olympic training camp: SAT tutors, resume builders, summer programs chosen to look good. The other is the family that does nothing until junior year and then panics. Both produce worse outcomes than a calmer middle path.

What actually matters

Grades

Freshman GPA is permanent. Every grade counts in the cumulative GPA that colleges see. A rough ninth-grade year can drag a strong junior record down in a way nothing else really can. The goal is not to take the most challenging schedule possible. It is to take a schedule you can handle well, and then level up sophomore year if the work is comfortable.

A small set of activities you actually like

Freshman year is for exploration. Try things. Quit what does not work. By the end of the year, one or two activities should be clearly worth keeping. Depth over the next three years is what admissions officers actually read for. The long activity list impresses nobody.

Habits, not credentials

Learning how to manage time, how to study, and how to ask a teacher for help is the hidden curriculum of freshman year. Students who figure out how to work outperform smarter students who never do.

What does not matter yet

  • SAT or ACT prep. The tests are two years away. Strong work in the math and reading you are doing in class is better preparation than any tutor.
  • Prestigious summer programs. Most pay-to-play summer programs for ninth graders are resume filler. Read books. Get a part-time job. Explore locally.
  • Starting a nonprofit. Join an existing organization first and learn how it actually works. The founded-a-nonprofit play is tired and admissions officers know it.
  • Formal college visits. Unless you are already in the area for something else, visits at this stage are overkill. Your preferences will shift a lot in two years.

The traps we see most often

01

Overloading on honors and AP.

Five honors classes freshman year to "challenge yourself" is how strong students end up with a 3.4 GPA. Start manageable, prove it, and add rigor sophomore year.

02

Joining everything.

Eight clubs so the activity list looks full signals that nothing was serious. Two or three with real commitment beats eight with none.

03

Burning out before sophomore year.

Junior year is where the workload actually spikes. Students who spent ninth grade overbooked arrive exhausted, not ready.

04

Writing off subjects you do not love.

You do not have to love every class. You do have to manage them. One weak subject can drag the GPA more than one strong subject helps.

A realistic freshman year

  • Academics. Strong grades in a course load that challenges but does not crush. Maybe one or two honors classes if they are comfortable.
  • Activities. Two or three things you genuinely enjoy. At least one you plan to continue.
  • Summer. Low-key and productive. A job, a skill, a local program, time to read. You do not need a prestigious internship.
  • Relationships. Two or three teachers who know you by name. These are the people who will write you recommendations in two years.
  • Mindset. Room to change. You will not be the same person in twelfth grade.

A note to parents

Optimizing early feels like love. The admissions landscape is scary and you want to give your kid an edge. But the students who arrive in senior year with real, interesting applications are usually the ones who had space to explore in ninth and tenth grade, not the ones who were pushed through a checklist.

A freshman does not need a college counselor yet. They need support, good habits, and room to figure out what they care about. That is the whole plan.

Helpful resources

Check the numbers for every college on the list

Free acceptance rates, early decision and test score ranges by year, from each college’s Common Data Set.

Want help applying this to your own plan? Foundations is our self-paced course for each step. Insider adds a dedicated advisor you can text or email, plus workshops, office hours and resume and application reviews.

Compare Foundations and Insider

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.