Writing an authentic Deerfield essay

November 2024EduAvenues Team3 min read

Deerfield admissions officers read thousands of essays a year. They are not looking for perfect grammar or impressive vocabulary. They are looking for a real student thinking honestly on the page.

The most common mistake is the opposite: an essay polished by several adults until the student is no longer visible. It reads as generic, and readers can tell. The fix is not to write worse. It is to write like the student actually talks and thinks.

Why authenticity wins

A small school like Deerfield is admitting a person into a dinner-table community. Every essay is a small sample of that person. A mechanically perfect essay about a generic topic tells them nothing about who will be in seat twelve at a sit-down meal. A specific, slightly rough essay about a real moment tells them a lot.

A workable four-step process

01

Brainstorm with open questions, not resume questions.

Do not ask the student what their most impressive accomplishment is. Ask what they genuinely changed their mind about recently, what small moment from the last year they cannot stop thinking about, or what they find fascinating that their friends find boring. Listen for the story that makes them lean in.

02

Pick a small, specific moment.

The strongest essays start from a concrete scene, not a thesis. "I am a resilient person" is a weak opening. "For three nights the robot's arm would not deploy" is a strong one. Reveal the larger point through the scene.

03

Write a messy first draft without editing.

The goal of the first draft is getting the story out, not making it good. Tell the student the draft does not need to be polished. It just needs to exist. The authentic voice shows up when nobody is grading it yet.

04

Revise for insight, not polish.

When you read the draft, resist the grammar pen. Ask what the moment meant, what the student felt, what they want the reader to take away. The work at this stage is sharpening the thinking, not smoothing the prose.

Patterns to avoid

  • The resume essay. A list of accomplishments. Replace it with one meaningful story.
  • Thesaurus syndrome. Vocabulary that does not sound like the student. Use the words the student actually uses.
  • The hero narrative. The student as flawless protagonist. Show growth and uncertainty instead.
  • Over-editing. Parent and counselor edits that sand off the student's voice. The essay should still sound like them after revisions.

What a strong Deerfield essay has

  • Specificity. A concrete moment, not a generalization.
  • Reflection. Evidence that the student has actually thought about what the moment meant.
  • Voice. Writing that sounds like a real teenager, not a polished adult.
  • Vulnerability. Willingness to describe a mistake, a change of mind, or a moment of uncertainty.
  • Fit. A natural connection, not a forced one, between the student's values and the kind of community Deerfield is.

The short version

Pick a real moment. Write it as it happened. Revise for meaning, not polish. Leave the rough edges that make it sound like a person. Deerfield is trying to decide whether they want to sit across a dinner table from you for four years. Give them something real to decide from.

Helpful resources

Start the Private School Admissions course free

Work through the first module of the self-paced course, free with any email and no card. Then use the free planner to date every step of the season, from school visits and the SSAT or ISEE to the January deadline.

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

More on Deerfield admissions

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.