Phillips Exeter interview tips

September 2024EduAvenues Team3 min read

After months of work on the application, the interview can feel like the scariest part. It does not have to. The Exeter interview is a conversation, not a test. The committee wants to understand who you are beyond the transcript, and you get to ask real questions about Harkness, campus life, and what the place is actually like.

What the interview is for

Three things are being assessed at the same time: whether you have the intellectual curiosity and collaborative instinct Harkness demands, whether you are mature enough to live away from home, and whether your interest in Exeter is specific and honest. Rehearsed answers work against all three. Interviewers read dozens of applicants a season and they notice the script.

Show curiosity, do not claim it

"I love to learn" is not an answer. A better version sounds like this: "We read about Roman law in history, and I got curious about how much of it still shows up in our legal system. I spent a few weekends on it and ended up writing a short comparison of a Roman code and the Constitution." Concrete beats abstract every time.

Tell a story, not a resume

Your interviewer has already read the application. They know you are captain of the debate team or first chair in the orchestra. What they want is the reason those things matter to you.

Instead of listing activities and awards, talk about what you learned when something went wrong. A robotics team whose robot broke at regionals and had to be redesigned for states tells a better story than a shelf of trophies. Failure and the response to it is almost always more interesting than a clean record.

Prepare the classics, but honestly

Some version of these will come up. Have real answers, not canned ones.

  • Why Exeter? Reference Harkness with specific understanding, a program you actually care about, or an aspect of student culture that fits how you work. Generic praise for "academic excellence" does nothing.
  • What book have you read recently? Pick one you genuinely enjoyed and can discuss. Do not name-drop something to sound impressive.
  • A challenge you have faced? A real one. Vulnerability and growth count for more than dramatic stakes.

Parents, coach do not direct

Help your child brainstorm stories, practice answering out loud, and think through why Exeter specifically fits. Do not write responses for them, do not make them memorize "perfect" answers, and do not sit in during practice. Over-coached students are easy to spot.

Prepare questions to ask

Three real questions is plenty. Ones we have seen work well:

  • On student life. "What surprised you about student life here when you arrived?"
  • On workload. "How do students balance the intensity of Harkness with extracurriculars?"
  • On fit. "What kinds of students tend to thrive here?"
  • On culture. "What is your favorite tradition?"

Common mistakes

  • Sounding rehearsed. Prepare ideas, not scripts.
  • Talking only about achievements. Exeter cares about character and curiosity at least as much.
  • Knowing nothing specific about Exeter. Generic enthusiasm for "top schools" is a red flag.
  • Letting nerves shut you down. One-word answers do not show who you are. Elaborate naturally.
  • Leading with rankings or prestige. Fit matters more than status to the people in the room.

The short version

The best interviews are not the ones with flawless answers. They are the ones where a real connection happens, and the interviewer walks out thinking, "this kid would be good at a Harkness table." Prepare enough to feel steady, then let yourself have the conversation.

Helpful resources

  • SSAT Official - Secondary School Admission Test
  • TABS - The Association of Boarding Schools
  • NAIS - National Association of Independent Schools

Start Exeter Prep Flex free

Work through the first module of Exeter Prep Flex, free with any email and no card.

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

More on Exeter admissions

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.