Compare the grants before you compare the campuses

October 28, 2026EduAvenues Team4 min read

Once you are admitted, the useful comparison is what your family would actually pay, and whether you would use the school. Johns Hopkins sets the regular-decision reply at May 1, 2027. Columbia, Dartmouth, and Georgetown also set that regular reply at May 1. Early decision is a different calendar: Hopkins asks Early Decision I admits to reply by January 15, 2027. The date printed on your offer is the deadline. A national “decision day” does not override it.

Read the grant money before you read the campus brochure. A grant or scholarship reduces the bill. A loan is an amount you still owe. Work-study is a job, not a discount. Two letters can show the same total “aid” and leave you with very different checks to write.

Reply dates you can plan around

Source: each college’s admissions site. These are regular-decision reply dates unless noted. Your offer letter controls if it prints a different day.
CollegeReply
Johns Hopkins, Regular DecisionMay 1, 2027
Johns Hopkins, Early Decision IJanuary 15, 2027
Columbia, Regular DecisionMay 1
Dartmouth, Regular DecisionMay 1
GeorgetownMay 1

Put the letters side by side and write down, for each school, the grants, the loans, and what is left for the family each year. Multiply the family share by four only as a sketch. Tuition changes, and a one-year grant is not a four-year promise unless the letter says it is. Hopkins says it meets full financial need. That is not the same dollar figure as another college that also says it meets need. The letters are the comparison.

If the prices are far apart, I would take the school the family can pay without a loan the student did not choose. If the prices are close, then the major, the city, and a day on campus decide it. Sit in a class in the department you named. See the housing you would actually get as a first-year, not the brochure quad. A visit will not reopen an admission decision. At Hopkins it was never an admissions factor. It can still tell you that you do not want to live there.

Greek life, climate, and a two-hour flight are real. They are real after the bill. Our note on Greek life is about asking the chapter what it costs before you treat it as the reason to pick the school. The admit-rate tables in the admissions data tool were for building the list. They are a weak way to choose between two offers you already have.

Questions families ask

When do you have to reply after a regular-decision admit?

Johns Hopkins sets the regular-decision reply at May 1, 2027. Columbia, Dartmouth, and Georgetown also set the regular reply at May 1. Early-decision replies are earlier. Hopkins asks for an Early Decision I reply by January 15, 2027. The date on your offer is the one that counts.

How do you compare financial aid offers?

Compare grants and scholarships first. That is the part of the letter that reduces the bill. A loan is still yours to repay, and work-study is a job you still have to get. Two letters with the same “package” can leave you owing very different amounts.

Should you visit before you decide?

Visit if you can, including a class and the place you would actually live. The visit is for you. At Johns Hopkins it does not change an admission decision that has already been made, and Hopkins does not track visits as interest. It can still change your mind.

What if the prices are close?

Then choose the school where the major is real and the week looks like a week you would keep. A ranking that ordered the two colleges is not a reason to take on a loan the family did not plan for.

Sources

Where to go next

Check the numbers for every college on the list

Free acceptance rates, early decision and test score ranges by year, from each college’s Common Data Set.

Want help applying this to your own plan? Foundations is our self-paced course for each step. Insider adds a dedicated advisor you can text or email, plus workshops, office hours and resume and application reviews.

Compare Foundations and Insider

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.