Published October 28, 2026.
Ask the teacher who can describe how you think, not the one with the most impressive title. Colleges do not all want the same number of letters. Johns Hopkins wants two teachers from different subjects, plus the counselor’s school report. Princeton wants two teachers from different core subjects, and a counselor letter that is separate from the school report. Ask in person if you can, at least three weeks before the deadline. A teacher writing for a dozen students in October cannot do much with a week’s notice.
What each recommender is for
Common App uses four roles. Counselors write about you in the context of the whole class and school, and they submit the transcript and school report. Teachers write about intellectual curiosity, writing, and work in their classroom. Other recommenders, such as a coach, employer, or arts teacher, write about work outside class, and only if that college accepts that type. Advisors can see your progress if you share it. They do not submit a letter.
| College | Teachers | Counselor | What they say about extras |
|---|---|---|---|
| Johns Hopkins | Two, different academic subjects | School report, including the counselor recommendation | Do not send additional recommendation letters |
| Princeton | Two, higher-level courses in different core subjects | Counselor recommendation, separate from the school report | Invite the counselor for both the school report and the letter |
The Common App requirements grid, updated September 25, 2026, lists every member's teacher-evaluation count. Use it for the rest of the list. Do not assume two letters because a neighbor's college asked for two. A college that wants one teacher letter is not asking for a second one.
Who to ask
Ask a teacher who has seen your work recently, usually junior or senior year, in a subject that matches how you want to be read. A student aiming at engineering is better served by a math or science teacher plus a humanities teacher than by two coaches. Hopkins is explicit: two different academic subjects. Princeton is explicit: core academics, and higher-level courses where the school offers them.
The right teacher is the one who can tell a specific story, not the one with the most famous title. A department chair who never taught you cannot do that. If you are unsure whether a teacher can write a strong letter, ask whether they can write one that is specific. A no is more useful than a vague letter. Common App says to ask before you send the invitation inside the application. An email is acceptable if you cannot ask in person.
Give the teacher the deadlines, the colleges, and a short page of facts they would not remember: the paper or lab you want them to mention, a hard week they watched you handle, and anything in the activities list that connects to their class. Common App provides questionnaires for this. The letter should still be theirs. Do not draft it for them.
Timing
Common App says to ask at least three weeks before a deadline, and that more notice produces a better letter. For a November 1 early deadline, that means asking by early October at the latest, and in September if the teacher is writing for many students. Track the status in the application. A missing letter is a missing piece of the file, not a detail the college will chase for you.
Thank the writer after the letter is in, and tell them the outcome in the spring. Common App says the thank-you matters. It also matters because you may need a later letter for a scholarship or a transfer.
Homeschool families should read the college's own rule. Johns Hopkins asks homeschooled applicants for a letter from an academic professional who knows the student and is not the parent or guardian who taught them. That is a Hopkins rule, not a universal one.
What a strong letter contains
Admissions readers already have the grade. The letter earns its place when it shows how the grade was earned: a question you kept after class, a revision that changed the argument, a lab that failed and what you did next. Praise without an example is the letter colleges already have in bulk. You help the teacher by handing them the example. You do not help by handing them adjectives.
The activities list and the personal statement should not repeat the letter, and the letter should not repeat the activities list. If the teacher is your only source for a story, let the letter carry it. Use the activities writing checklist, which is free and needs no account, to see whether your own entries already say what the letter would say. The personal statement is for the part of you the classroom does not show.
Questions families ask
How many recommendation letters does the Common App require?
The Common App does not set one number for every college. Each college chooses how many teacher evaluations it requires and which other recommenders it accepts. Check that college’s page in the application, or the Common App requirements grid.
When should a student ask for a letter?
Ask before you send the invitation in the application, in person if you can. Common App says to ask at least three weeks before the deadline. Earlier is better for a November 1 early deadline.
Who should write the teacher letters?
A teacher who taught you in class and can describe how you think. Johns Hopkins wants two teachers of different academic subjects. Princeton wants two teachers of higher-level courses in different core subjects, such as English, history, a language, science, or math.
Is the counselor letter the same as the school report?
No. Princeton says the school report and the counselor recommendation are separate items, and the counselor should be invited for both. Johns Hopkins asks the counselor to send the school report, which includes the counselor recommendation, the transcript, and the school profile.
Should a student send extra letters?
Only if that college accepts them. Johns Hopkins tells applicants not to send additional letters of recommendation. Another college may allow an optional other recommender, such as a coach or employer. Read that college’s rule.
Sources
- Common App, Understanding the recommendation process, September 2026: recommender types, asking first, and at least three weeks' notice.
- Common App, application guide for first-year students, what counselors, teachers, and other recommenders each submit.
- Common App requirements grid, 2026-27, updated September 25, 2026. Each college's teacher-evaluation count.
- Johns Hopkins, application requirements, two teacher evaluations and the counselor school report.
- Johns Hopkins admissions FAQ, do not send additional recommendation letters; homeschool letter rule.
- Princeton, application checklist, two teacher recommendations and a counselor recommendation separate from the school report.