Your first Harkness class at Lawrenceville looks like this: an oval table, about a dozen students, a teacher who is more of a participant than a lecturer, and no back row to hide in. The conversation is the curriculum.
It can feel intimidating on day one. It is also the piece of a Lawrenceville education that most alumni say changed how they think. Here is how to get good at it.
It starts before you sit down
Do the reading. Not "skim it." Actually read it, annotate it, and show up with a couple of real questions.
Write in the margins. Underline what confuses you. Mark the sentence you would bring up if the teacher asked. Those notes are your material when the conversation starts. Without them, you are reacting, and reacting alone is not enough to contribute meaningfully.
What a strong contribution looks like
- Listen first. The best students track the conversation closely and notice when someone has opened a door worth walking through. Waiting for your turn to talk is not listening.
- Build. Add evidence or nuance to a point someone already made. Good Harkness discussions stack up, they do not reset every minute.
- Bridge. Connect two ideas the table has not linked yet. This is where real insight tends to show up.
- Branch. Move the conversation into a new, productive direction when it has stalled.
- Ask. A precise question can reshape a discussion more than a long answer. "Why did the author end the chapter there?" beats "What did everyone think?"
Common traps
Dominating.
Talking too often or over people reads as self-focused, not smart. Quality over quantity. If you have spoken twice in ten minutes, hold back.
Staying silent.
Silence feels safe and reads as disengaged. If you are nervous, start small. Ask a clarifying question or build one sentence on someone else.
Filling the air.
You do not have to say anything if you do not have something to say. A thoughtful pause is better than a wandering comment.
Performing.
Harkness rewards curiosity, not polish. Do not reach for big words or rehearsed lines. Say what you actually think and let it be messy.
The real goal
Mastering Harkness is not about being the smartest voice at the table. It is about being the one that makes the rest of the table smarter. When you leave a class having learned something because of a question you asked, or because of what a classmate said in response to a point you made, you are doing it right.
Helpful resources
- Lawrenceville School - Official school site
- Phillips Exeter on Harkness - Background on the method
- NAIS - National Association of Independent Schools