How to earn a glowing recommendation letter

August 2024EduAvenues Team2 min read

You cannot force a glowing letter. You can create the conditions for one. That means building a real relationship, showing real growth, and making it easy for the teacher to write about you with specifics rather than generalities.

The families we work with who get the strongest letters are the ones who treated this as a year-long process, not a spring-of-junior-year ask.

Choose the right teachers

Good choices. Junior year core academic teachers who have seen you engage. Ideally one STEM and one humanities. Teachers who can speak to how you think, not just what you scored.

Weak choices. Teachers who only know you earned an A. Ninth and tenth grade teachers. Famous or beloved teachers who do not actually know you. Non-academic teachers, unless a school specifically asks.

Build the relationship before you ask

Engage in class. Ask the kinds of questions a curious person asks, not the kind a grade-motivated one asks. Visit office hours. Follow up on an idea from a lecture. Show growth in their class across the year.

By the time spring rolls around, the teacher should have a mental file of specific moments that describe you. Those specifics are what make a letter memorable.

Ask the right way

Ask in April or May of junior year. Do it in person, then follow up by email so you have the logistics in writing. The phrase that works is "Would you feel comfortable writing me a strong letter of recommendation?" The word "strong" gives them an out if they do not think they can.

Make it easy for them

Provide a one-page brag sheet. Not a resume. A short document with:

  • Three to five specific accomplishments or moments from their class.
  • A sentence or two on how their class shaped what you want to study.
  • Your college list and intended major.
  • Deadlines laid out cleanly.

The brag sheet is not a script. It is a prompt that helps the teacher remember the things that would be easy to forget under deadline.

The short version

Relationship first, letter second. Be a student your teacher can write about in specifics, make the ask easy, and give them the raw material to do it well. That is how the good letters actually get written.

Helpful resources

Check the numbers for every college on the list

Free acceptance rates, early decision and test score ranges by year, from each college’s Common Data Set.

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.