ISEF's judging criteria give 25 of 100 points to the interview

November 21, 2026EduAvenues Team8 min read

The Regeneron ISEF judging criteria suggest scoring each project out of 100 points across five sections, and the largest section, worth 35 points, is the presentation, which combines the poster and the interview. Society for Science publishes the criteria its Grand Award judges use, while each affiliated fair sets its own judging method. This guide lays out the published criteria and what each one asks of a student, then covers the poster and booth rules a project has to meet at ISEF.

The ISEF Grand Award scoring rubric

The Society publishes separate criteria for science projects and engineering projects. Both have five sections and the same point values, and the only difference is what the first three sections ask about. Fairs differ in how they score, since the Society says every affiliated fair has its own judging methodology, so confirm your own fair's rubric as well.

Regeneron ISEF Grand Award judging criteria (Society for Science).
SectionPointsScience project asksEngineering project asks
I. Research question or problem10A clear and focused purpose, a contribution to the field, testable by scientific methodsA practical need or problem, criteria for the solution, constraints explained
II. Design and methodology15A well designed plan and data collection methods, with variables and controls definedAlternatives explored, a solution identified, a prototype or model developed
III. Execution20Systematic data collection and analysis, reproducible results, appropriate math and statistics, enough data to support the conclusionsA prototype that matches the design, tested in multiple conditions or trials, showing engineering skill and completeness
IV. Creativity and potential impact20Significant creativity in one or more of the other criteria, and impact or potential impact in the field or in technology, economy, environment or society
V. Presentation, poster10Logical organization, clarity of graphics and legends, supporting documentation displayed
V. Presentation, interview25Clear, concise, thoughtful answers, understanding of the basic science, of the interpretation and limits of results, and of the degree of independence, recognition of potential impact, quality of ideas for further research, and for teams the contribution of every member

The Society adds that considerable emphasis is placed on two areas, creativity and presentation, especially the interview. A student who has done the experiment well but cannot explain it will lose much of the largest block of points. The interview alone, at 25 points, is worth more than the execution section.

What each section asks of a student

The research question

Judges look for a purpose that is clear, focused and testable, and for a student who can say what the project would add to the field. In practice, this means a student should be able to state the question in one sentence and say why anyone would care about the answer. Projects that start with a demonstration, a literature review or an explanation model are not recommended for ISEF, and we would expect a project that is really a build of something known, with no open question, to struggle here.

Design and methodology

This section is about whether the plan could have worked, before looking at whether it did. For a science project, that means defined variables, controls and a sensible way to collect data. For an engineering project, it means the student explored alternatives before settling on a solution. In our experience, students are weakest here when they cannot explain why they chose a control, a sample size or a design. The research plan the ISEF rules require before experimentation, with its rationale, procedures, risk and safety and data analysis, is where that reasoning should already be written down.

Execution

Systematic collection, reproducible results and an appropriate statistical method are the core of the science criteria, and testing under multiple conditions or trials is the core of the engineering criteria. The Society's guidance for judges says to look for evidence of laboratory, field or theoretical work, not just library research or gadgeteering. A neat notebook is persuasive evidence, since judges are told to examine the student notebook.

Creativity and potential impact

Creativity here means imagination and inventiveness, often a different perspective that opens new possibilities. Impact is the project's actual or potential effect on a field, technology, the economy, the environment or society. If the impact has not been demonstrated, the criteria ask whether the student recognizes and can envision it. The Society tells judges to put emphasis on research outcomes and analysis when judging creativity, so a clever idea that was never tested is unlikely to score as well as a tested one.

The poster and the interview

The poster is worth 10 points and is meant to make the interview an in-depth discussion instead of a tour. The Society encourages clear and informative posters that allow pre-interview evaluation. The interview carries 25 points and covers understanding of the basic science, the interpretation and limits of the results, how independent the student was, and ideas for further research. Judges are told that for work done at a research institution or industrial setting, they should determine how independent the student was, as documented on the regulated research institution form, and that for work done at home or in a school lab they should find out whether the student received mentoring or guidance.

What judges are told to look for

The Society's advice to fair judges is a useful guide for students because it shows the priorities. Judges are told that the physical display is secondary to the student's knowledge of the subject, that only research conducted within the current year should be evaluated, and that they should compare projects only with those at the fair they are judging. They are also told to use an encouraging tone, to work out how much guidance the student received, and to treat the interview as the high point of the fair for most students. For multi-year projects, the ISEF criteria say the interview should focus only on the current year's work, and the continuation form helps judges see what is new.

Team projects are scored on the same rubric as individual ones, so teams do not get a different standard. Every member is expected to show significant contribution and understanding, and one of the interview criteria is the contribution of all members. A team where only one person can answer the technical questions will lose points on that line.

Poster and booth rules at ISEF

Some problems at the booth come from compliance, not content, and the Display and Safety rules are checked during the set-up and inspection process. At ISEF, a finalist's project may take up no more than 76 centimeters in depth, 122 centimeters in width and 240 centimeters in height, including table covers. The abstract that appears at the booth must be the stamped version issued after the Scientific Review Committee's approval, and students are told not to use the word "abstract" as a title on their own materials. Every graphic the student creates must be cited with the software used and the year, such as "Photo taken by Finalist, Year," and graphics from other sources need their own citations. Photos of people other than the finalist need signed releases, which are kept in a notebook and not displayed, and completed informed consent forms are not allowed in the exhibit hall at all. The display and abstract must show only the current year's work, and raw data from earlier years cannot be displayed.

On artificial intelligence, the ISEF rules say a student may use AI as a project resource if it is cited, but may not use generative AI to write the research plan, abstract or poster, or to create citations. AI-created graphics are acceptable when cited as AI created, with the date and the tool.

Judging at ISEF itself

Each ISEF project is judged at least four times. The Society says about 1,000 science, engineering and industry professionals judge each year, and they have a Ph.D. or equivalent degree or six years of relevant experience. Grand Award judges review display boards, then conduct interviews in 15-minute periods before meeting in caucuses to decide the category winners. For ISEF 2027 in Los Angeles, the Society schedules Grand Award judging interviews to begin on Wednesday, May 12, 2027, at 9:30 a.m. The Society reports that finalists overwhelmingly say their most significant interactions at the fair are with the judges.

The Regeneron Science Talent Search uses a different approach, and families who enter both should not assume the rubrics match. STS evaluators score four areas, which are the research report and scientific merit, the student's contribution, academic aptitude and achievement, and overall potential as a future leader, and the Society says it does not share rubrics. The Junior Science and Humanities Symposium lists its own criteria, which include the research problem, scientific thought and creativity, design and procedures, a logical conclusion, skill in communicating results and references. If your student is preparing for several, our guides to the Science Talent Search, qualifying for ISEF and JSHS cover each one separately.

Preparing for the interview

In our experience, the interview points are the easiest to improve in the last month before a fair. We ask students to practice a two-minute summary and then answer questions from an adult who has not seen the project, because a judge outside the field asks the questions a parent often skips. The questions students most often struggle with line up with the interview criteria, such as why they chose a variable, what would change their conclusion, what the limits of the data are, what their mentor did and what they did, and what they would test next. Students who have written those answers in their notebook months earlier tend to give shorter and clearer responses than students who try to construct them under pressure.

For more on choosing a project that can carry that kind of discussion, see our guide to science fair projects past a demonstration. The free research programs deadline list shows other dates worth knowing.

If your student wants a structured way to turn a project into a finished paper, the Research Scholars program is a 12-week guided mentorship that takes a high school student from a research question to a paper prepared for journal submission.

Helpful resources

Find a research program or competition that fits

Our free deadline list covers research competitions, summer research programs and student journals, checked against each official site.

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.