A 1350 SAT or 28 ACT puts a student in the most awkward part of the test-optional era. Not low enough to be obvious. Not high enough to be safe. The right answer is rarely "send everywhere" or "skip everywhere." It is school-by-school.
The whole decision turns on one number: the school's 25th percentile for admitted students. Below that line, your score is working against you. At or above it, you are inside the conversation.
The 25th percentile rule
Every school publishes the middle 50 percent of admitted students' scores. If a school's range is 1400 to 1540, the 25th percentile is 1400. Use it as a hard line.
- At or above the 25th percentile. Submit. Your score is doing work for you.
- 10 to 30 points below. Judgment call. Lean on whether the rest of your application is strong without the score.
- 50 or more points below. Do not submit. The score is hurting you more than its absence will.
Where your score sits
A rough orientation, not a substitute for looking up each school:
- 1500 plus. Submit almost everywhere. There is no school where this hurts.
- 1400 to 1490. Submit at top-30 to top-50 schools and most flagships. Consider going test-optional at top-10 or top-20 reaches.
- 1300 to 1390. Submit at top-50 to top-100 schools. Go test-optional anywhere meaningfully more selective.
- 1200 to 1290. Submit at less selective schools. Go test-optional from there up.
When to submit even if borderline
- STEM majors at schools where math performance reads as part of the academic case.
- Schools that "recommend" rather than "require" scores. Recommend usually means submit.
- Large public flagships where holistic review is shallower and a score can carry weight.
- Applicants with a softer GPA who need a second academic data point.
When test-optional is the better play
- Strong GPA with the most rigorous courses available.
- Genuinely standout extracurriculars or a sharp personal story.
- Schools that have stayed test-optional on principle rather than under pressure.
- Most liberal arts colleges, which tend to read applications more deeply.
What admissions officers actually do without a score
They assume the score was below the school's range. That is fine when the rest of the application carries the academic case. It is not fine when scores were the strongest piece you had. Withholding a score is only an upgrade if the rest of the file is genuinely strong.
Use your superscore
Most schools superscore the SAT and many superscore the ACT. If a 1280 and a 1310 superscore to a 1350, run your decision off the 1350, not either single sitting. Check each school's policy. Some still take only the highest single sitting.
The short version
Look up each school's middle 50 percent. Compare your superscore to the 25th percentile. Submit when you are at or above. Skip when you are well below. Decide school by school. There is no blanket answer to a borderline score.
Helpful resources
- College Board - SAT and college planning
- ACT Official - Official ACT test information
- FairTest - Updated lists of test-optional schools