What to do if you get deferred

December 2025EduAvenues Team3 min read

A deferral letter is not a no. It is a school telling you they want to see how you compare against the regular pool before deciding. That distinction matters, and the actions you take in the next few weeks can move the needle.

The honest part: at highly selective schools, deferred applicants are admitted at low rates. The actions below help your odds. They do not guarantee anything, and you should put real energy into your other applications in parallel.

The first 48 hours

Read the deferral letter carefully. Some schools tell you exactly what to send and what not to send. Follow whatever they say. If they ask for nothing, you will still want to send a Letter of Continued Interest later, but not today.

Do not email admissions in the first day to express disappointment or ask what went wrong. Give yourself a beat. If this was an ED deferral, the binding agreement is over and you are free to apply ED II elsewhere or finish your regular decision list.

The Letter of Continued Interest

The LOCI is the main tool you have. It should be one page or shorter, and it does three things: confirms the school is still your top choice (if it is), shares meaningful updates since you applied, and adds one or two specific reasons the fit still holds.

  • Opening. Brief acknowledgment of the deferral and that the school is still your top choice.
  • Updates. New grades, awards, projects, or developments worth knowing.
  • Fit. One or two specific reasons the school is still the right match. Not generic.
  • Close. Thank them, sign off.

Send it after fall semester grades are final, typically mid-January to early February, and before the school's regular decision read happens. Earlier than that and you have nothing new to say.

What to leave out

  • Complaints about the deferral.
  • Requests for an explanation of the decision.
  • Pleading or anything that reads as desperate.
  • Repeating content already in your application.
  • Anything you cannot back up.

Other ways to strengthen the file

Strong fall grades are the most useful update you can send. Make sure the school receives the mid-year report. If you retook the SAT or ACT and the score actually moved, send it. If you have access to a recommender who can speak to a different side of you (employer, coach, mentor), one extra letter is fine, provided the school accepts them and the letter adds something new.

A lukewarm extra letter is worse than none.

What not to do

01

Do not bombard the admissions office.

One LOCI plus the updates the portal asks for is enough. Multiple emails or calls read as anxious.

02

Do not have a parent intervene.

You write the letter. You handle the communication. Parent involvement is a flag.

03

Do not send gimmicks.

Cookies, videos, packages. They do not help and they sometimes hurt.

04

Do not let senior grades slip.

A downward trend after deferral seals a rejection more reliably than anything else on this list.

05

Do not stop working on other schools.

Energy spent perfecting one LOCI is not a substitute for finishing the rest of your applications well.

The short version

Read the letter, follow its instructions, send a tight LOCI in mid-January with real updates, keep your grades up, and put your best work into the rest of your list. Then let it go. The students who eventually get pulled off the deferral pile are not the ones who tried hardest after the fact. They are the ones whose application happens to fit the class the school is shaping.

Helpful resources

Check the numbers for every college on the list

Free acceptance rates, early decision and test score ranges by year, from each college’s Common Data Set.

Want help applying this to your own plan? Foundations is our self-paced course for each step. Insider adds a dedicated advisor you can text or email, plus workshops, office hours and resume and application reviews.

Compare Foundations and Insider

Get the next guide by email

A short series from Neil, our co-founder, on what we tell families every admissions season, then occasional updates.

Unsubscribe anytime.

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.