Most people never ask for a raise, and those who do often do it poorly. They wait too long, ask at the wrong time, or fail to make a compelling case. The professionals who understand how to advocate for themselves earn significantly more over their careers. Here is how to approach the conversation.
Step 1: Know when to ask
Timing is crucial. Asking at the wrong moment can tank an otherwise solid case.
Good times to ask: After a major win or successful project. During annual review cycles. When taking on significant new responsibilities. When the company is doing well financially.
Bad times to ask: During layoffs or hiring freezes. Right after a missed deadline or mistake. When your manager is under extreme stress. Less than a year into the role.
Step 2: Build your case
Managers are not looking for reasons to give you more money. You need to make a compelling case that frames the raise as deserved and reasonable.
Evidence to gather:
Accomplishments
Specific wins with quantified impact (revenue, savings, efficiency).
Expanded Scope
New responsibilities taken on since last raise or hire.
Market Data
What similar roles pay at other companies (Glassdoor, Levels.fyi, Payscale).
Positive Feedback
Emails, reviews, or quotes from colleagues praising your work.
Know your number. Research what comparable roles pay and come with a specific number or range. Asking for a percentage increase feels abstract. Asking for a specific salary feels grounded in research. Aim 10-20% higher than what you would accept to leave room for negotiation.
Step 3: Have the conversation
Schedule a dedicated meeting. Do not spring this in a hallway conversation or at the end of a 1:1 about other topics.
Sample script: "I wanted to talk about my compensation. Over the past [time period], I have [specific accomplishments]. My role has expanded to include [new responsibilities]. Based on my research, similar roles are paying [range]. I am asking for [specific number] to bring my compensation in line with my contributions and the market."
Keep it professional, confident, and focused on value delivered. Avoid personal financial needs as justification.
- Do: Focus on value. Tie your request to specific contributions, impact, and market data.
- Do: Be specific. Ask for a concrete number rather than a vague increase.
- Avoid: Personal justifications. Your rent increase or student loans are not your employer's problem.
- Avoid: Ultimatums. Do not threaten to leave unless you are truly prepared to do so.
Step 4: Handle the response
If they say yes
Get the details in writing. When does it take effect? Is it retroactive? Follow up with an email summarizing the agreement.
If they say not now
Ask what specific milestones you would need to hit for reconsideration. Get a timeline and follow up accordingly.
If they offer less
Negotiate for other benefits: bonus, title, additional PTO, remote days, professional development budget.
If they say no
Ask for specific feedback on what would need to change. Decide if you want to stay or start looking elsewhere.
The power of documentation. Throughout the year, keep a brag document listing your wins, positive feedback, and expanded responsibilities. When it is time to ask for a raise, you will have everything you need at your fingertips instead of scrambling to remember what you did.
Helpful resources
- Bureau of Labor Statistics - Occupational Outlook Handbook, career data and projections
- LinkedIn Learning - Professional development courses
- Handshake - Early career job platform for students