Salary negotiation: get what you are actually worth

January 2026EduAvenues Team4 min read

Almost every offer has room. Recruiters expect a counter, hiring managers have already mentally added a buffer, and the company has approved budget that no one will volunteer. The reason most people accept the first number is not that the number is right. It is that negotiating feels uncomfortable.

The good news is that the conversation is shorter and less confrontational than it feels. Here is the version that consistently works.

Before the offer arrives

Do the research first. Levels.fyi for tech, Glassdoor and LinkedIn for general benchmarks, Blind for anonymous data points, and your own network for the most honest read. Decide three numbers before any conversation: the floor you will walk away below, the target you would happily accept, and the stretch you will open with.

Understand the whole package, not just base. Sign-on, annual bonus target, equity grant and vesting, benefits, PTO, remote flexibility, title, and start date are all on the table. Some of those are easier to move than base.

When the offer comes in

Do not accept on the call. Do not reject either. Thank them, say you are excited, and ask for time and the full written offer. A version of: "Thank you, I am really excited. I would like to review the complete package. When do you need a decision?" buys you everything you need.

Then ask for the details in writing: bonus target, vesting, valuation if private, benefits summary. Anything verbal that you care about should end up in a document.

The counter

Counter at or above your stretch number. There is room to move down, never up. Lead with enthusiasm, justify with market data and what you bring, and end with a question, not a demand. Something like: "I am excited about this and can see myself making an impact. Based on my research and my experience in [specific area], I was hoping we could get the base closer to $X. Is there flexibility there?"

Ask for one specific number, not a range. Be ready to negotiate other components if base is genuinely capped.

Handling the response

If they say yes, get the revised offer in writing before formally accepting. If they counter, you can usually go back one more time before it gets awkward. If they say no on base, ask about sign-on, equity, additional PTO, an earlier review, or a higher level. One of those usually moves.

"This is our final offer" is sometimes true and sometimes a tactic. The honest test is whether other components have any flex. If nothing moves, take that as data and decide based on your floor.

The hard questions, scripted

  • "What are your salary expectations?" Deflect: "I am focused on finding the right fit. Can you share the budgeted range for this role?" If pressed, give a research-backed range with your target as the bottom.
  • "What is your current salary?" Illegal to ask in many states. "I would prefer to focus on what is appropriate for this role and the value I bring."
  • "We need an answer by tomorrow." Manufactured urgency. "I am very interested but want to be fully committed when I accept. Can we extend to [reasonable date]?"

Common ways people lose money

  • Accepting on the spot. Even when you love the offer, ask for time. The signal it sends matters.
  • Apologizing. "I hate to ask" frames the conversation as inappropriate. It is not.
  • Giving a range. You will get the bottom. Always.
  • Inventing a competing offer. If they verify it, the offer is gone. Not worth it.
  • Negotiating only base. Sign-on and equity often have more room than salary at large companies.
  • Going adversarial. The recruiter is not the enemy. Stay collaborative; you are about to work with these people.

The short version

Research, three numbers, do not accept on the call, counter at your stretch with a specific number, and stay friendly. Most candidates who do this come out ahead. The candidates who do not are the reason there is a budget left to negotiate against.

Helpful resources

Have your resume reviewed before you send it

Written, line-by-line feedback on content, clarity, format and applicant tracking systems, within 48 hours.

EduAvenues Team

Practical guidance from the EduAvenues team for students and families making high-stakes academic and career decisions.