A recent piece in The Atlantic, "Accommodation Nation," reports that a striking share of students at elite universities are now registered with a disability accommodation. At Stanford the number is about 38 percent. At Brown and Harvard it is over 20 percent. At UC Berkeley it has grown dramatically over the past 15 years.
There are real questions to ask about who these systems were designed for and who is using them. But here is what I keep coming back to, and it is something I saw firsthand during my time at TJ. The families behind those numbers are not doing anything illegal. They are navigating a system that exists and using the tools available to them.
If you are a parent wondering how to advocate for your child, the first step is understanding that advocacy itself is not only allowed. It is expected, at least by the families who are already doing it.
What I saw at TJ
Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology is one of the most competitive public high schools in the country. Getting in is hard. Staying afloat is harder. And the students who thrived were not always the ones with the highest raw ability. They were the ones who understood how the game worked.
- They learned the teachers. Who offered extra credit, who did not, who was approachable after class.
- They requested schedule changes. When a section was not working, they asked to switch instead of suffering through.
- They pushed back on grades. Respectfully, with evidence, when they had a case.
- They chose activities strategically. Not just based on interest, but based on what would compound.
- They asked upperclassmen for advice and followed it.
Their parents were usually just as engaged. They showed up to back-to-school night with questions. They met with counselors before problems became crises. They did not assume the school would figure it out on their kid's behalf. That is what advocacy actually looks like in practice. It is not aggressive. It is not entitled. It is engaged.
Strategic is not unethical
There is a difference between working the system and crossing an ethical line. Working the system means understanding what options exist and pursuing them: asking for a tutor, requesting a different class section, exploring whether your child qualifies for services, reaching out to a teacher to discuss a plan for improvement. Crossing the line means dishonesty: fabricating a diagnosis, misrepresenting abilities, paying someone to write essays.
Most families I work with are nowhere near the line. Their problem is the opposite. They are so worried about seeming pushy that they do not advocate at all. They wait for the school to reach out. They assume that if something were available, someone would have told them. Meanwhile, other families are asking every question, requesting every meeting, and researching every opportunity. Those families are not cheating. They are just participating more actively than everyone else.
Why parents hold back
After hundreds of conversations with families, the same hesitations show up over and over. "I do not want to be that parent." "I do not want to make things awkward for my kid." "The school knows what is best." "Other families have more resources, so what is the point."
I understand the instinct, especially if advocacy was not modeled for you growing up. But the families already advocating loudly are not going to stop. If you stay quiet, you are not leveling the playing field. You are just ceding ground. Learning to advocate does not mean becoming a helicopter parent. It means being informed, asking questions when things do not make sense, and treating your child's education like the high-stakes situation it is.
Where to start
Learn what your school actually offers.
Tutoring, counseling, academic coaching, accommodations. Many schools have resources that are underutilized because families do not know they exist. Have you asked?
Initiate a conversation before there is a problem.
Not in response to a bad grade. Proactively. Just to check in. Teachers and counselors remember the parents who show up early.
Teach your child to self-advocate.
Asking for extra help, requesting an extension when overwhelmed, talking to a teacher after class. Some kids figure this out on their own. Most need to see it modeled first.
Test whether the rules are really rules.
Course requirements, schedule constraints, activity eligibility. Many of these have more flexibility than families assume. You will not find out unless you ask.
What this looks like in practice
Real scenarios I have seen play out:
- The section change. A parent notices their child is struggling with a teacher whose style does not click. Instead of waiting out the semester, they ask the counselor how a section switch could work. The counselor says it is not typical. The parent asks what would need to be true. A week later the switch goes through.
- The accommodation request. A family realizes their child's anxiety is affecting test performance. They pursue an evaluation, receive a diagnosis, and request accommodations through the school's official process. Grades improve. No rules were broken.
- The placement test. A student wants an advanced class but does not meet the listed prerequisites. The parent reaches out to the department head, explains the background, and asks if there is a pathway. There is a placement test. The student passes and gets in.
None of these families did anything wrong. They just did not assume "no" before they heard it.
Be unapologetic
The conversation around The Atlantic piece will keep going, and there are real tensions worth discussing. But the broader lesson for parents is not about accommodations specifically. It is about mindset.
The students who succeed at competitive schools are the ones who ask questions, research their options, and treat the system as something to be understood and navigated, not passively accepted. They stay ethical. They do not lie or cheat. And they do not apologize for being proactive. If your child needs something, ask for it. If a path seems unconventional, explore it. If something feels like it is "not done," find out whether that is a rule or an assumption. Top students work the system. Make sure your family knows how to, as well.
Until next time,
Neil
Co-Founder, EduAvenues
Helpful resources
- The Atlantic: Accommodation Nation - The piece referenced in this post
- College Board - College planning and admissions resources
- NACAC - National Association for College Admission Counseling