Published October 28, 2026.
A waitlist spot is a maybe that the college may never use. For fall 2025, Harvard's Common Data Set says 75 students were admitted from the waitlist, and it does not say how many were offered a place. Yale offered 944 students a place, 738 accepted it, and 32 were admitted. Both colleges say the list is not ranked. Deposit at a school that has already said yes. Then follow the waitlist instructions in that college's portal, and stop.
The counts colleges actually filed
| College | Offered a place | Accepted the place | Admitted from the list | Ranked? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Harvard | Not reported | Not reported | 75 | No |
| Yale | 944 | 738 | 32 | No |
| NYU | Blank | Blank | Blank | Not answered in the file |
Harvard's same CDS reports 47,893 first-year applicants, 2,003 admitted, and 1,675 enrolled for fall 2025. Those are the regular admission counts. They are not a waitlist rate. Dividing 75 by a number Harvard did not publish would be a guess.
Yale's 32 admits are real, and so is the pool. About 4.3 percent of the students who stayed on the list were admitted. That is one year at one college. It is not a national waitlist rate, and it is not a prediction for the next class. NYU's blank cells are a reason not to quote an NYU waitlist percentage from a blog.
Why the list exists
Colleges admit a class before they know who will enroll. The share who enroll is yield. Harvard's first-year page tells Restrictive Early Action admits they have until May 1 to reply, and the Dean of Students Office says May 1 is the deadline to say you intend to enroll. Yale's timelines page sets May 1 for admitted students in both Early Action and Regular Decision, and it says a student offered the Regular Decision waitlist may respond by May 1.
On April 2, 2021, Yale admissions officers Mark Dunn and Hannah Mendlowitz said on the admissions podcast that the office does not know, before that reply date, whether it will take zero students from the list or many. They said that is why the list is not ranked. The 2025-26 CDS still marks the list as not ranked. A family email that assumes a hidden rank order is arguing with the form.
The same episode is plain about April. The office is spending that month on students who were admitted. Calling, visiting in order to lobby, or organizing other people to write does not improve the case. They also said the college wants to move quickly after May 1, and that some years there is no room.
What to do, in order
- Reply to the waitlist offer by the date in the letter. Yale says a Regular Decision waitlist offer may be answered by May 1. A spot you do not accept is a spot the college will not use.
- Deposit at a college that admitted you, by that college's reply date. Harvard's is May 1, and it does not require a deposit. Another college's date is on its own letter. Do not spend May unenrolled in the hope a waitlist call arrives.
- Send an update only if the portal still accepts one. Yale's applicant contact page describes an update form for active applicants: new information, a document, a test score. Recommendation letters still have to come from a counselor or another school official, not from a stack of new advocates. The 2021 podcast's warning was about volume. One new fact is not a second application.
- Do not invent a rank, a word limit, or a national success rate. If the college's instructions name a form, use that form. If they are silent, silence is a safer reading than a letter copied from another school's blog.
A deferral from an early round is a different status. The application is still in the regular pool. The guide on deferrals is the one to use for that letter. This page is the spring waitlist, after a decision.
Questions families ask
How many students did Harvard admit from the waitlist?
Harvard’s Common Data Set for 2025-26 says 75 wait-listed students were admitted for fall 2025. It leaves blank the number of students offered a place on the list and the number who accepted it. The list is not ranked. Without the first two counts, there is no honest waitlist admission rate for that year.
How many students did Yale admit from the waitlist?
Yale’s Common Data Set for 2025-26, for fall 2025, reports 944 applicants offered a place, 738 who accepted it, and 32 admitted. The list is not ranked. Of the students who accepted a place, 32 divided by 738 is about 4.3 percent. That is a calculation from Yale’s counts, not a rate Yale prints.
Does NYU publish waitlist numbers?
NYU’s 2025-26 Common Data Set says it has a waitlist policy. The counts for students offered a place, students who accepted, and students admitted are blank. A blank is not zero. Do not borrow another college’s waitlist admit rate.
When do colleges go to the waitlist?
Harvard tells admitted students the reply deadline is May 1. Yale’s timelines page sets the same date for admitted students, and it says a student offered a Regular Decision waitlist spot may respond by May 1. In an April 2, 2021, admissions podcast, Yale officers said they do not know how many students they will take from the list until after admitted students reply, which is why the list is not ranked.
Should you call the admissions office every week?
Yale’s 2021 podcast says no. The officers said April is when they are working with admitted students, and that repeated calls, a campus visit meant to lobby, or a pile of updates does not help. Accept the waitlist spot by the college’s deadline, send only what that college’s portal asks for, and deposit at a college that already admitted you.
Sources
Checked October 28, 2026.
- Harvard College Common Data Set 2025-2026. Section C2, and the fall 2025 applicant counts.
- Yale College Common Data Set 2025-26. Section C2.
- NYU Common Data Set 2025-2026. Waitlist policy with blank counts.
- Harvard College, first-year applicants. May 1 reply for admitted students.
- Harvard College Dean of Students Office. May 1 enrollment reply.
- Yale College timelines. May 1 for admits, and for a Regular Decision waitlist response.
- Yale admissions podcast, April 2, 2021. Why the list is not ranked, and what does not help in April.
- Yale admissions, how to send an update.