Exeter requires recommendations from your current English teacher, your current math teacher, and a principal or counselor. You can also send an optional personal recommendation. On paper that is just a checklist. In practice, these letters are one of the clearest signals the admissions office has about whether you will actually thrive in a Harkness classroom.
The goal is not to collect letters. The goal is to give two teachers, who each have maybe ninety minutes to write about you, enough specific material to write about you well.
Why English and math specifically
Harkness is built on discussion, writing, and analytical thinking. English and math teachers see those skills every day. The committee is reading their letters for answers to a simple question: would this student hold their own at the table.
Choosing the right recommenders
The teacher who gave you the highest grade is not automatically the right choice. The right choice is the teacher who can write about you as a thinker in specifics.
- Relationship depth. Do they know your thinking, your growth, and how you participate, or just your grade?
- Writing quality. Do their comments on your papers go past "great work"? Detailed graders write detailed letters.
- Harkness fit. Can they describe you in a discussion, asking a question, building on someone else's point?
- Enthusiasm. Do they seem genuinely glad to be asked? Reluctant yeses become lukewarm letters.
Warning signs include a teacher who only knows you as "the quiet A student," a teacher new to your school, a large-class lecturer with minimal interaction, or any hesitation when you ask.
How to ask
Ask in person, early, and with an out. Something like:
"I'm applying to Phillips Exeter and I need a recommendation from my English teacher. You're the teacher who knows me best in that subject. Would you be comfortable writing a strong recommendation for me?"
The word "strong" is deliberate. It gives them permission to say no, which is a kindness to both of you. A hesitant yes becomes a tepid letter.
Follow up with an offer to send them a short information sheet with the school, the deadline, and a few reminders about your work in their class.
Timing
Ask four to six weeks before the deadline at minimum. For a mid-January Exeter deadline, September or early October is ideal. Teachers write better letters when they are not rushed, and you want to be at the front of the queue, not the back.
The information sheet you give them
A one-page brag sheet is one of the highest-leverage things you can do. Teachers write for many students. Without material, they default to generalities. With material, they write about you.
Include:
- Specific classroom moments. The discussion where you argued something unusual, the paper where you took a risk, the week you struggled with a concept and came to office hours.
- Intellectual interests in their subject. Books you read outside class, questions you pursued on your own, connections to other subjects.
- A growth story. Something you were not good at that you got better at, and what changed.
- Classroom dynamics. How you participate, how you help classmates, how you handle a conversation you are losing.
- Why Exeter. A short, honest sentence or two about what pulls you there. Harkness, specific programs, something real.
Be specific, not humble. If you do not give them material, they cannot write with material.
What a strong letter looks like
Strong letters share a few traits. They tell specific stories (not "curious about history" but "asked about the economic angle the textbook skipped"). They describe how you behave in discussion. They put you in comparative context ("among the stronger essays I've read in fifteen years of teaching"). They address character, not just grades.
Weak letters do the opposite. They are short, full of generic praise, use hedging language like "one of the better students," and omit any mention of how you actually engage in class.
You will not see the letter, but you can shape it by whom you ask and what you give them.
The optional personal recommendation
Use the optional slot only if the person can show the committee something your academic letters cannot. A coach who has seen your leadership, a long-term music teacher, a summer employer, or a community service supervisor can all work.
Skip it if your best option is a family friend, a paid tutor, a second academic teacher, or someone your parents know better than you. A mediocre optional letter is worse than no optional letter.
Common mistakes to avoid
Asking too late.
Two weeks out is too late. Rushed letters are weak letters.
Choosing by grade instead of relationship.
A B+ teacher who watched you grow writes a stronger letter than an A teacher who barely knows you.
Not providing a brag sheet.
Without it, the teacher defaults to generalities. This is the single highest-leverage thing you control.
Asking by email.
The first ask is in person. Email is for logistics after the yes.
Skipping the follow-up.
A polite check-in about a week before the deadline is welcome, not annoying.
Forgetting to thank them.
A handwritten note after they submit is professional and memorable. It also matters for the next time you need a letter.
The short version
Ask the teacher who knows you as a thinker, not the teacher who gave you the highest grade. Ask in person, at least a month out, with an out. Give them a one-page sheet of specific material. Thank them. The letter they write will do its job.
Helpful resources
- Phillips Exeter Admissions - Official admissions site and application requirements
- SSAT - Secondary School Admission Test
- TABS - The Association of Boarding Schools